BOOK REVIEW: Valentine’s Day by Joyce K. Kessel

Valentine’s Day by Joyce K. Kessel

My rating: 3 of 5 stars


Some have said, “Don’t judge a book by the cover,” and I would say, “Valentine’s Day by Joyce Kessel is one of those books.” The cover for this book is pretty dated at this point, and reminded me of old books from the 1980’s I would check out from the library as a kid. However, while the cover doesn’t do much to inspire the imagination, the story and black and white illustrations with red highlights raise this book above others.

This book is perhaps the most robust and yet succinct retellings of the history of Valentine’s Day I have found yet. The story also doesn’t hide the origins of the holiday regarding Pope Gelasius I’s appropriating the Feast of Juno and recreating it as “St. Valentine’s Day” in honor of one or all of the three St. Valentine’s we know of from history. The book tells a few stories about the various Valentines, each one labeled as a “legend.” The book then goes on to explain the traditions of the holiday and how it has translated to modern times.

This book is longer than some other picture books for kids on Valentine’s Day. It also has some potentially not great ideas that young readers might pick up without some conversation from parents. There is discussion later in the book of “penny dreadfuls,” valentine cards sent during the late 1800’s that were meant to be insulting. A parent might want to read that section ahead of time and decide whether they want to talk about that section or not. It would be a good opportunity to have a discussion with your kid about the words we use towards others and how we can encourage others rather than tear them down.

The illustrations range from fun in a 1920’s throwback way to highly dated in a 1980’s children’s book way. Throughout, red is sprinkled into the black and white drawings, which is an interesting detail.

If you find this one at a local library, it’s worth a checkout and a read, especially if you have a child interested in the history across the span of 2,700 years of Valentine’s Day.

BOOK REVIEW: Valentine’s Day Is… by Gail Gibbons

Valentine’s Day Is by Gail Gibbons

My rating: 3 of 5 stars


Having read a few picture books on Valentine’s Day, I found Gail Gibbons’ Valentine’s Day Is… to be a fun, well-illustrated book that contained information I have not seen in other books on the holiday.

Each page is set up with the phrase: “Valentine’s Day Is…” and is finished with things like “candy,” “love,” or “hearts.” The pages then go on to explain very simply and succinctly various traditions and symbols related to Valentine’s Day, including Saint Valentine and ancient Roman practices of putting names in an urn and drawing them, similar to today’s valentine cards and valentine mailboxes so many kids make.

Those looking for historical information on Saint Valentine will find only a copy of pages on him here, which are very sparse in actual information. At the end of the book there is a great DIY Valentine project that is simple and fun as well.

The illustrations are bright, vibrant, and have a bit of a 1900’s throwback vibe in some places that made them especially charming. Kids will love searching the pictures for all the hearts throughout the book and hidden away in each picture in fun ways.

If you’re looking for a fun read on Valentine’s Day, this is a book that would be a great library checkout, but perhaps not one to purchase.

BOOK REVIEW: Valentine’s Day by Ann Heinrichs

Valentine’s Day by Ann Heinrichs

My rating: 2 of 5 stars


Ann Heinrichs’ Valentine’s Day picture book is an overview of the holiday for young readers. This book covers more of the traditions and symbols behind the holiday rather than any specific history of how the day came to be. There is a short “chapter” here on Saint Valentine as well as the Roman festival Lupercalia on February 15th, but both comprise about five pages total with a quick brush through history.

One particular feature of this picture book is the numerous poems and quotes from literature throughout the ages. From anonymous poems to Shakespeare to Plato, there are plenty of fascinating snippets from poems that will give kids an introduction to literature talking about Valentine’s Day as well as love in general.

The illustrations here are fine, but they aren’t exactly thrilling, interesting, or exciting. Many of the illustrations seem rather typical for this kind of non-fiction children’s book and none of the pictures really stand out.

There are also some activities for kids in the back of the book, including recipes, DIY crafts, and some suggestions for ways to celebrate Valentine’s Day.

If you’re looking for an overview book of the holiday, this book is fine, but there are certainly more fascinating books out there on Valentine’s Day. If you’re looking for more information on Saint Valentine, this is not the book to go to.

BOOK REVIEW: Saint Valentine by Robert Sabuda

Saint Valentine by Robert Sabuda

My rating: 3 of 5 stars


With Valentine’s Day fast approaching, I wanted to take a look at the various books about the holiday as well as the Saint it’s named for. Saint Valentine by Robert Sabuda was one of the first books I found on the Saint specifically, and didn’t expect the emotional impact this beautifully illustrated picture book would have on me.

Written as a sort of historical fiction of a snippet from the life of Saint Valentine, the book shares about the work Valentine did as a healer and a chance encounter one day with a jailer and her daughter who cannot see. While Valentine is sorry that he cannot do more for the jailer’s daughter, he starts to pray for her. I won’t spoil the ending here, but it definitely had the emotional punch that good storytelling will deliver.

The story is light on Valentine’s religious beliefs, and has a brief more historically accurate explanatory note at the end. The story implies the death of Valentine, but does not mention it specifically.

The illustrations however are amazing. Sabuda takes a mosaic approach to each page, which create intricate details that weave together to form mesmerizing pictures that instantly draw your gaze. Kids will definitely enjoy searching the pictures for some time to see all the details and then to zoom out and see the larger illustration as a whole.

While this isn’t the most comprehensive book on Saint Valentine, it certainly tells a poignant story that illustrates the life of the saint.